DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post - Answer to a Barelwi regarding kissing thumbs during athan!

**Dndjzirw** · 11-24-2010, 05:26 PM

brother. Don't get angry unnecessarily. We are not trying to teach Shaykh 'Afifi al Akiti his madhhab. We are presenting the evidence here and leaving it for everyone to decide on his own so that tomorrow people who stare at someone who recites the durood on Nabi(saws) on hearing his name instead of kissing his thumbs will be able to understand how wrong they are and how right the person who follows the Sunna is. WS.

exactly, you presenting evidence. but what if we dont have the tools to take that evidence & make a ruling ourselves. we go to people like sh Afif. once again you said that those who kiss thumbs are wrong.
so in your opininon since the sh mentioned that there various ahadeeth although weak- is there any chance that Abu Bakr RA was a thumb kisser so is he also among the wrong dowers.

im not angry by the way. if shafi's going to a deoband institute dont know their own usool then I cant see a hanafi from a deoband institute to say that sh afif is wrong. its obvious that in his view its mustahab as in his article. now since berelwis do it does it make it completely wrong. tomorrow we will hear that its biday to wear a green turban.

11-24-2010, 05:26 PM	#18
Dndjzirw Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 535 Senior Member	brother. Don't get angry unnecessarily. We are not trying to teach Shaykh 'Afifi al Akiti his madhhab. We are presenting the evidence here and leaving it for everyone to decide on his own so that tomorrow people who stare at someone who recites the durood on Nabi(saws) on hearing his name instead of kissing his thumbs will be able to understand how wrong they are and how right the person who follows the Sunna is. WS. exactly, you presenting evidence. but what if we dont have the tools to take that evidence & make a ruling ourselves. we go to people like sh Afif. once again you said that those who kiss thumbs are wrong. so in your opininon since the sh mentioned that there various ahadeeth although weak- is there any chance that Abu Bakr RA was a thumb kisser so is he also among the wrong dowers. im not angry by the way. if shafi's going to a deoband institute dont know their own usool then I cant see a hanafi from a deoband institute to say that sh afif is wrong. its obvious that in his view its mustahab as in his article. now since berelwis do it does it make it completely wrong. tomorrow we will hear that its biday to wear a green turban.
	Quote