LOGO
Reply to Thread New Thread
Old 07-10-2012, 02:23 PM   #1
clapsoewmred

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
618
Senior Member
Default ashari/maturidi vs hanabilah/athari aqeedah differences are acceptable
Salam

one of the ideas one gets from listening to this lecture below by SHaykh Sham Ud Duha and Mufti Kamaluddin (in the case of the latter the point is touched upon but it is by no means the focus of his talk),

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fisz2...feature=relmfu

http://www.islamicspirituality.org/l.../ayyuhal-walad

http://www.deoband.org/2010/04/hadit...utes-of-allah/

As well as this article from Mufti Taqi Uthmani is that the differences of opinion between the asharis, maturidis, atharis, those who assign a location to Allah those who don't, those who take a literal interpreatation of Allahs attributes, those who don't delve into them at all, and those who provide a metaphorical interpretation (with restrictions of course) all fall within the accepted realm of scholarly disagreement.

Often times people will say that muslims are defined by their aqeedah, and thus there can be differences of opinion in fiqh BUT NOT in AQEEDAH. The idea that one gets from the pieces of infromation that i have provided is that this is not the case. there are acceptable differences in aqeedah as well (within bounds obviously), without anyone running the risk of being labelled deviant or out of the fold of ahlussunnah.
clapsoewmred is offline


Old 07-10-2012, 05:13 PM   #2
Konservir

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
397
Senior Member
Default
As well as this article from Mufti Taqi Uthmani is that the differences of opinion between the asharis, maturidis, atharis, those who assign a location to Allah those who don't, those who take a literal interpreatation of Allahs attributes, those who don't delve into them at all, and those who provide a metaphorical interpretation (with restrictions of course) all fall within the accepted realm of scholarly disagreement.

Often times people will say that muslims are defined by their aqeedah, and thus there can be differences of opinion in fiqh BUT NOT in AQEEDAH. The idea that one gets from the pieces of infromation that i have provided is that this is not the case. there are acceptable differences in aqeedah as well (within bounds obviously), without anyone running the risk of being labelled deviant or out of the fold of ahlussunnah.
Salam `Aleykum,

I was writing a big reply to this but the electricity cut off so I lost it... To be brief, when people understand that all of this falls under the legitimate difference of opinion in Islam, 70% of the Fitnah which is dividing the Muslims will disappear to no return.. but the people are dumb idiots so they'll keep on debating and I don't expect them to understand anytime soon.
Konservir is offline


Old 07-10-2012, 08:38 PM   #3
stadiaKab

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
422
Senior Member
Default


Do you mean all are within Ahlus Sunnah then? Many would disagree with you; in fact, many would disagree with you seemingly considering the athari aqeedah to be the same as that of the Salafi's. The reason why some Ulema make it a big issue is because they (justifiably) don't want people to be of those who stray from the Ahlus Sunnah and if they consider Salafi aqeedah to be outside of it, they will obviously bring it up, warn people, etc.

stadiaKab is offline


Old 07-10-2012, 10:22 PM   #4
Logaleta

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
419
Senior Member
Default
Salam `Aleykum,

I was writing a big reply to this but the electricity cut off so I lost it... To be brief, when people understand that all of this falls under the legitimate difference of opinion in Islam, 70% of the Fitnah which is dividing the Muslims will disappear to no return.. but the people are dumb idiots so they'll keep on debating and I don't expect them to understand anytime soon.
ameen to that bro

we got more important things to work for

lets see if people will accept their scholars when the fatwa doesnt suit their desires

inshAllah sunnis unite together and work for common good whilst keeping their different schools restricted to the mosques and maintan adab towards each other
Logaleta is offline


Old 07-11-2012, 12:51 AM   #5
Konservir

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
397
Senior Member
Default


Do you mean all are within Ahlus Sunnah then? Many would disagree with you; in fact, many would disagree with you seemingly considering the athari aqeedah to be the same as that of the Salafi's. The reason why some Ulema make it a big issue is because they (justifiably) don't want people to be of those who stray from the Ahlus Sunnah and if they consider Salafi aqeedah to be outside of it, they will obviously bring it up, warn people, etc.

wal `Aleykum el-Salam

Why would he say "accepted realm of scholarly disagreement" if it's outside the Quran and Sunnah?
Konservir is offline


Old 07-11-2012, 02:03 AM   #6
tLO0hFNy

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
511
Senior Member
Default
Salam

one of the ideas one gets from listening to this lecture below by SHaykh Sham Ud Duha and Mufti Kamaluddin (in the case of the latter the point is touched upon but it is by no means the focus of his talk),

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Fisz2...feature=relmfu

http://www.islamicspirituality.org/l.../ayyuhal-walad

http://www.deoband.org/2010/04/hadit...utes-of-allah/

As well as this article from Mufti Taqi Uthmani is that the differences of opinion between the asharis, maturidis, atharis, those who assign a location to Allah those who don't, those who take a literal interpreatation of Allahs attributes, those who don't delve into them at all, and those who provide a metaphorical interpretation (with restrictions of course) all fall within the accepted realm of scholarly disagreement.

Often times people will say that muslims are defined by their aqeedah, and thus there can be differences of opinion in fiqh BUT NOT in AQEEDAH. The idea that one gets from the pieces of infromation that i have provided is that this is not the case. there are acceptable differences in aqeedah as well (within bounds obviously), without anyone running the risk of being labelled deviant or out of the fold of ahlussunnah.
this is true, the beliefs of the Atharis and Ashari/Maturidis are still the same in all but a few non-central areas, its just everyone blows these differences out of all proportion.
tLO0hFNy is offline


Old 07-11-2012, 02:05 AM   #7
tLO0hFNy

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
511
Senior Member
Default
Salam `Aleykum,

I was writing a big reply to this but the electricity cut off so I lost it... To be brief, when people understand that all of this falls under the legitimate difference of opinion in Islam, 70% of the Fitnah which is dividing the Muslims will disappear to no return.. but the people are dumb idiots so they'll keep on debating and I don't expect them to understand anytime soon.
Allah was helping you write a concise answer .
tLO0hFNy is offline


Old 07-11-2012, 03:29 AM   #8
Konservir

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
397
Senior Member
Default
Allah was helping you write a concise answer .
It was a rant Akhi
Konservir is offline


Old 07-11-2012, 05:00 AM   #9
clapsoewmred

Join Date
Oct 2005
Posts
618
Senior Member
Default
A few notes I want to add here:

Accepting another person`s opinion as being within the valid range of scholarly discourse in no way means you agree with their opinion.

to take an example from fiqh: no hanafi, shafi , or maliki who is being true to his tradition will say that it is permissible to read juma`salah before dhuhr time. and we would warn others of our school of thought from doing so. as we would consider there juma`to then be invalid (a lot more can be said on this subject but i`m only giving you the point form answer).

however, a hanbali and by extension a salafi would opt for that opinion based on the fact that it has been established wirthin the hanbali school, not withstanding the constant "but it`s such a weak opinion" view that hanafi, maliki, or shafi ulema would hold. the fact is that if the opinion had been established within their school they could of course follow it without fear of being labelled deviant or nafs-followers based on the fact that the opinion is accepted within their school (they have no allegiance to our school so why on earth would they care what we have to say about it's permissibility or impermissibility).

however i would of course caution fellow hanafis from adopting that practice because it is completely at odds with our ulema/tradition and not permissible....i.e. you can't pray salah before its time and according to us juma time only begins when dhuhr time begins, so sorry no 12:00pm lunch hour jumas.

while my school of thought does not agree with the opinion, we don't go around saying oh you dudes (meaning the hanbalis or salafis) are all deviant and are following extremely weak opinions etc etc. (obviously they don't view it as being soooo weak or they wouldn't have followed it). Obviously i would have an issue with them pulling a hanafi into that, or enforcing that one view on everyone else. but if that's not the case they do as they please so long as it is in accordance with their madhab or what THEY VIEW to be their madhab, let not hanafi dictate what that hanbali should or should not do and vice versa.

with this issue of aqeedah things are not soo different, aqeedah does not automatically mean that everyone must agree 100% on every small detail. No one holds an anthropomorphic concept of Allah, despite using vocab some may deem problematic, because despite the language used there is still an element of relegation. refer to Mufti Taqi uthmani's article. thus the key issue of allah being different from creation is still maintained....anyways i've said about all i want to on the subject of aqeedah...i already feel a bad taste in my mouth by mentioning the word "anthropomorphic".

or for example another issue comes up which is regarding the life of the prophet (saws) in his grave. one shaykh says his life is just like his life in this world (with a few minor differences e.g. he doesn't have to eat he is sustained by allah etc.) the other group says no actually his life is very different form the life of this world because he doesn't eat or drink etc....the above two views are almost exactly the same it's the way the statement is framed really, everyone accepts that he has a very special life in the grave.

granted in the case of the aqeedah differences regarding Allah's attributes i'm not saying that everyone suddenly say oh yeah we're all completely the same so lets just forget the aqeedah (or the details) that we believe in, rather i'm saying hold on to whatever you have (I rather like the way Mufti Abdrurrahman Ibn Yusuf explains things, and have no intention of giving up my views to adopt another school of thought), but don't go to the extent that you now forget that we still agree on the basic principles and disagree only on details i.e. the peripherals not the essentials (not my words by the way Shaykh Shams Ad Duha's words).

what was it that Shaikhul-Hind Mawlana Mahmudul Hasan said....something about "kissi or ka maslak chiro naih, apni maslak badalo naih" (my urdu is pretty bad)

paraphrased translation: don't change your maslak/manhaj/school of thought, and don't try to change anyone else's either.

unfortunately i don't have tripoli sunni's way of wording things briefly.
clapsoewmred is offline


Old 04-16-2020, 10:50 AM   #10
Stellachuler

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1
Junior Member
Default
In Muslim every one not known of the difference between the Ashari Maturidi and the Handbill that is the worrying thing for all Muslim. In that case they contact get information from the ivory research reviews which will be having the positive talk about them.
Stellachuler is offline


Old 04-17-2020, 03:29 PM   #11
lorinb3

Join Date
Mar 2020
Posts
79
Member
Default Hot new pictures each day
Sexy pictures each day
Free Shemale Porn Pictures at X Shemale Pics
porn video sharing wesites free barley leagal teen porn best free amateur porn movies tight porn hot my husband watches internet porn
lorinb3 is online now


Old 04-17-2020, 03:34 PM   #12
lorinb3

Join Date
Mar 2020
Posts
79
Member
Default Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
Free Porn Galleries - Hot Sex Pictures
The best porn video for free
rey porn adult anime porn dvds mad porn thumbnails babes porn outdoors greatest porn video ever
lorinb3 is online now


Old 04-17-2020, 03:40 PM   #13
lorinb3

Join Date
Mar 2020
Posts
79
Member
Default Teen Girls Pussy Pics. Hot galleries
Hot galleries, thousands new daily.
Shemale Models Collections
patty cake porn star fucking ali hilfiger porn dizney porn toons female friendly porn sites hardcore porn vintage
lorinb3 is online now


Old 04-20-2020, 02:41 AM   #14
wl3

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,566
Senior Member
Default Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
Hardcore Galleries with hot Hardcore photos
The best porn video for free
free gerbil porn hotel erotica streaming porn share porn video brunnette porn star huge tits constance marie fake porn
wl3 is online now


Old 04-20-2020, 02:43 AM   #15
wl3

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,566
Senior Member
Default Enjoy daily galleries
My new hot project|enjoy new website
Shemale and ladyboy picture galleries
sex porn pros thumbs west coast production free porn dense masino free porn porn fetish rubbing keely hazell porn
wl3 is online now


Old 04-20-2020, 02:52 AM   #16
wl3

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,566
Senior Member
Default New super hot photo galleries, daily updated collections
Sexy photo galleries, daily updated collections
Watch porn videos in good quality HD
tiana free safe porn best top porn sites kelly beekman porn sci fi porn videos teen sex porn orgy
wl3 is online now


Old 04-20-2020, 05:26 AM   #17
fw60

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,381
Senior Member
Default Free Porn Pictures and Best HD Sex Photos
Free Porn Galleries - Hot Sex Pictures
Sex Video tube, daily new videos
little girl naked porn submitted teen porn daddy fucks boy porn hugh jackman gay porn deelishes porn video
fw60 is offline


Old 04-20-2020, 05:30 AM   #18
fw60

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,381
Senior Member
Default Dirty Porn Photos, daily updated galleries
Scandal porn galleries, daily updated lists
Sex Video tube, daily new videos
best porn india nude sex caught on tape porn porn selebrti free yong porn video girl on gril porn free picx
fw60 is offline


Old 04-20-2020, 05:32 AM   #19
fw60

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,381
Senior Member
Default Best Nude Playmates & Centerfolds, Beautiful galleries daily updates
Hot galleries, daily updated collections
http://freesaxlessons.miaxxx.com/?jenny
sons of female porn stars porn star green eyes thai porn review xxx safe free internet porn neil patrick harris porn
fw60 is offline


Old 04-20-2020, 05:38 AM   #20
fw60

Join Date
Apr 2020
Posts
1,381
Senior Member
Default Sexy photo galleries, daily updated pics
Teen Girls Pussy Pics. Hot galleries
http://swollenanusporn.danexxx.com/?maura
porn naughty cam amateur porn gallery rimming teen porn lesbian porn completely free young bbw porn tube
fw60 is offline



Reply to Thread New Thread

« Previous Thread | Next Thread »
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 

All times are GMT +1. The time now is 03:24 AM.
Copyright ©2000 - 2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Friendly URLs by vBSEO 3.6.0 PL2
Design & Developed by Amodity.com
Copyright© Amodity