[JohnTruels]

Deleted

[ephennaCypota]

asalaamualaikum. I am going to order ' the students Bahishti zewar for males. Is this a good book. as many of the people I know have reccomended this book as good,

Yes it is good. I think the "students version for males" is especially for learning from, the layout is different and there are also questions after every topic i think, unlike the original Bahishti Zewar.

[ovH9wfSJ]

It is good indeed,and very helpful.

[rorsvierwelia]

if you want to learn masail from Bahishti Zewar, Dr. Mufti Abdul Wahid sahib's "Masail-Bahishti Zewar " is very useful.

[inilbowly]

asalaamualaikum

I know it's one of the most popular book. One of my brother told me, this book has some stupid masail!!?. i will ask help from this forum members to help me. i will collect what is stupid masail in this book from that brother.

[rorsvierwelia]

asalaamualaikum

I know it's one of the most popular book. One of my brother told me, this book has some stupid masail!!?. i will ask help from this forum members to help me. i will collect what is stupid masail in this book from that brother.

feel free to share his stupidity with us

[inilbowly]

feel free to share his stupidity with us

asalaamualaikum

Usman bhai

as i could remember he told me about dog slaughtering with saying bismillah in Bahishti Zewar (BZ). is there any internet version to read BZ? if yes, plz provide link.

[inilbowly]

asalaamualaikum

anyone? any web link to download BZ pdf?

[rorsvierwelia]

asalaamualaikum

anyone? any web link to download BZ pdf?

here's the english translation : http://www.scribd.com/doc/16758748/H...13-Hanafi-Fiqh

[hellenmoranov]

asalaamualaikum. I am going to order ' the students Bahishti zewar for males. Is this a good book. as many of the people I know have reccomended this book as good,

It's a must have book. Purchase it and don't even think twice, insha'Allah you will be glad you did.

wallahu a'alam,
wassalaam.

[AntonioMQ]

As far as the stupidity is concerned, its what people who have plenty of time to waste (ghair muqallids) raise over and over again.
The dog slaughtering refers to a ruling in the hanafi mazhab which applies that any animal slaughtered with a knife causing the blood to flow shal become pure (except human and pigs).
ما طهر جلده بالدبغ طهر بالذبح. (النقاية والهداية) اهـ
What they don't understand is that it does not mean in any way that the meat of such an animal becomes halal, as Hazrat Thanwi has clearly stated himself.
He further said that this ruling applied in medicine where doctors had to use parts of such animals during surgery , e.g. cats intestines to stitch internal wounds.
Another point they miss is that dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab, like hyenas in the hanbali mazhab.
But its the "Jihad" they are waging against the ahnaf/deobandis that blinds them from such facts.

[inilbowly]

As far as the stupidity is concerned, its what people who have plenty of time to waste (ghair muqallids) raise over and over again.
The dog slaughtering refers to a ruling in the hanafi mazhab which applies that any animal slaughtered with a knife causing the blood to flow shal become pure (except human and pigs).
ما طهر جلده بالدبغ طهر بالذبح. (النقاية والهداية) اهـ
What they don't understand is that it does not mean in any way that the meat of such an animal becomes halal, as Hazrat Thanwi has clearly stated himself.
He further said that this ruling applied in medicine where doctors had to use parts of such animals during surgery , e.g. cats intestines to stitch internal wounds.
Another point they miss is that dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab, like hyenas in the hanbali mazhab.
But its the "Jihad" they are waging against the ahnaf/deobandis that blinds them from such facts.

asalaamualaikum

very nice answer.

What they don't understand is that it does not mean in any way that the meat of such an animal becomes halal, as Hazrat Thanwi has clearly stated himself. he told me they r agree with Hazrat Thanwi that meat is harma.
but question is slaughtering dog, is it allowed in islam?
another question he told, without tanning how leather is pure to use?

Another point they miss is that dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab, like hyenas in the hanbali mazhab for slaughtering?

[DYjLN8rF]

but question is slaughtering dog, is it allowed in islam?

is there any prohibition?if the dog meat is haram to it, for which sake people will slaughter it? with any valid reason? if not then its sin of killing animals.

for slaughtering?

when anything si halal, it refers that you may use it or eat it. how do you eat animals meat without slaughtering it brother?

[blodwarttufla]

asalaamualaikum. I am going to order ' the students Bahishti zewar for males. Is this a good book. as many of the people I know have reccomended this book as good,

I have a copy of this version of Behishti Zewar as well and I highly recommend it.

[inilbowly]

is there any prohibition?if the dog meat is haram to it, for which sake people will slaughter it? with any valid reason? if not then its sin of killing animals.
when anything si halal, it refers that you may use it or eat it. how do you eat animals meat without slaughtering it brother?

asalaamualaikum

Oh my brother, plz give me an answer without asking any question that i can place ur answer to them.
if u ask me a question then how can i place an answer to them.

Another point they miss is that dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab, like hyenas in the hanbali mazhab. dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab for slaughtering or to make a PET?

like hyenas in the hanbali mazhab for slaughtering or to make a PET?

i think u can understand me. if i can understand ur answer then i can place it correctly to them

[inilbowly]

here's the english translation : http://www.scribd.com/doc/16758748/H...13-Hanafi-Fiqh

asalaamualaikum

thanks Usman bhai
i also got another source

part1
Part2

[AntonioMQ]

but question is slaughtering dog, is it allowed in islam?

Slaughtering of any animal for no reason is deifinitely prohibited.
But if there is a valid reason then it is allowed. But keep in mind that valid reason is not limited to eating.
Its because the only slaughtering we are used to is when done for eating, but Allah has created all these creatures for human to use in whatevery way permissible.
Now say a doctor requires a certain part of a dog/haraam animal for the treatment of a human, if he takes it from a dead animal it will be impure because all dead animals are impure. To make it pure the animal should first be slauhgtered. It will then become pure for use, but the question of eating it still is bound to whether the animal itself is halal or not.

[AntonioMQ]

another question he told, without tanning how leather is pure to use?

Tanning is used to purify leather that is impure. The leather of ميتة i.e. dead , is impure as is every other part of their body. But when any animal is properly slaughtered it becomes pure, leather included. So taning is done to the leather of animals which died without slaughtering.

[AntonioMQ]

dogs are halal according to some jurists of the maliki mazhab for slaughtering or to make a PET?

i meant for eating after slaughtering.

[arraxylap]

i meant for eating after slaughtering.

yuk.