DiscussWorldIssues - Socio-Economic Religion and Political Uncensored Debate - View Single Post

**MeatteCen** · 12-03-2011, 04:24 PM

Bro, What I have heard/read is that shias can be a part of the sanad(chain) of a reliable hadith. Thats not the issue here.

BUT

Shias have hadith of their own. Most of them is start like Imam Jafar said... or Imam Fulan said... without any sanad. I m not disregarding the authenticity of Imam Jafar (ra) but the Shias have falsely attributed many hadith to Him WITHOUT a proper sanad to Rasoolullah or the Sahabah.

If you look closely the hadith in question, is there a source for it? Is it mentioned any of the Hadith collections?

Precisely.

The easiest way to check is to look through the books of Tafsir like Ibn Kathir, Ma'ariful Qur'an etc.

Is this story mentioned under Surah Aali 'Imran:135-136?

Definitely not in Ma'ariful Quran, can anyone confirm for the other books of tafsir?

Otherwise it can't be that such a "hot" story escaped the eyes of all our sunni mufassireen for 1300 years right?

If anyone has access to the other tafsir books kindly check through and post your findings here.

12-03-2011, 04:24 PM	#14
MeatteCen Join Date Oct 2005 Posts 507 Senior Member	Bro, What I have heard/read is that shias can be a part of the sanad(chain) of a reliable hadith. Thats not the issue here. BUT Shias have hadith of their own. Most of them is start like Imam Jafar said... or Imam Fulan said... without any sanad. I m not disregarding the authenticity of Imam Jafar (ra) but the Shias have falsely attributed many hadith to Him WITHOUT a proper sanad to Rasoolullah or the Sahabah. If you look closely the hadith in question, is there a source for it? Is it mentioned any of the Hadith collections? Precisely. The easiest way to check is to look through the books of Tafsir like Ibn Kathir, Ma'ariful Qur'an etc. Is this story mentioned under Surah Aali 'Imran:135-136? Definitely not in Ma'ariful Quran, can anyone confirm for the other books of tafsir? Otherwise it can't be that such a "hot" story escaped the eyes of all our sunni mufassireen for 1300 years right? If anyone has access to the other tafsir books kindly check through and post your findings here.
	Quote