[skupaemauto]

If the dog attacked a human without a cause, I agree the dog definitely needs to be put down.

If the dog attacks a dog without a cause, no, I will not put that dog down.

Sounds like Heidi was still in the heat of the moment. Did she nip or bite anyone while she was broken off of the other dog? Did she re-direct at all?

Magnus and Hawken got into a yard accident. Now anytime I walk past Magnus with Hawken (well really any of the other males), Magnus goes nuts wanting to get to them. I keep him around. Why? Because he didn't re-direct on me when I broke the fight up, and has never shown any aggression toward me or any other humans. I just do my best to make sure he says properly contained at all times.